The Role Of Books

Posted by Stuart Herbert @ 7:47 PM, Wed 15 Oct 08

Filed under: Teaching

No Comments

In last week’s Beginners’ class, we enjoyed a great discussion about the books I recommend on this website, and which books are of any use to someone just starting learning the art.

My own experience with books over the years is three-fold:

  1. As a beginner, I simply had no common frame of reference to understand the great advice available in the great Tai Chi books.  Looking back in recent years, I can now see that many of the answers I’ve sought were there under my nose the entire time, but I simply didn’t understand enough to see that.
  2. There are a great many Tai Chi books that (imho) are utter rubbish.  I don’t mean that they are written badly, but that the advice they contain is demonstrably wrong.  Much to my wife’s disgust, I collect these almost as avidly as I do the better books, and my students can look forward to the day when I share these books with them, and ask them to pick out the many flaws they contain :D
  3. The books that could be called authentic are a great source of advice.  I was taught to take nothing on faith, to always seek out and verify everything I was taught by Robert.  New information can promote a path of experience to new understanding, and in the light of new information things must change.

You can’t learn from a book.  Knowledge comes from a book, but understanding only comes from experience.  Books can’t replace a good teacher, but they can certainly validate good teaching.  And they can expose bad teaching too.

Did you enjoy this article? If so, subscribe to my RSS feed.

Calendar

October 2008
S M T W T F S
« Jul    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031